Ultrasonic Transducer Product Development Consulting
Blog Layout
Hard PZT vs. Soft PZT as an off-resonance actuator
Husain Shekhani • Oct 23, 2020
Hard PZT vs. Soft PZT as an off-resonance actuator
Let me ask a question. Is hard or soft PZT a better off-resonance actuator?
We all know that Soft PZT has superior d-coefficent aka piezoelectric charge coefficient. This means that a soft PZT element will exhibit more displacement for a given drive voltage( off-resonance). It will also produce more charge than hard PZT, given a specified load.
So is soft PZT better than hard PZT for off-resonance actuator applications? And if so, by how much?
Comparing a hard PZT and a soft PZT, we can find that the d coefficient is roughly twice as large. However, the d coefficient as a actuator only relates to a piezoelectric element by itself – not bonded to an external structure. Its like saying a Ferrari is fast car, but can it tow a trailer? In order to understand how much a piezo material can “tow”, you need to look at the compliance.
Hard PZT has a lower compliance (higher stiffness) than soft PZT. What this ends up meaning is that the performance gap between hard PZT and soft PZT in terms of an off-resonance actuator becomes less when considering the compliance.
This can be accomplished via d33/s33^E. For this ratio, soft PZT is only 1.6x better than hard PZT, not 2x. Please see my videos on piezoelectric actuators, blocking force, and the piezoelectric stress coefficient here: https://www.learnpiezo.com/lectures#lecture7
Please let me know if you have questions and comments on this topic at husain@ultrasonicadvisors.com. Also please send your colleagues this email and ask them to subscribe if you think they would benefit from these emails. This is the subscription link: [Link to subscribe]
Regards,
Husain Shekhani, PhD
Ultrasonic Advisors
husain@ultrasonicadvisors.com
Follow the link here to learn about my ultrasonic transducer consulting services and prices
Did you like this post?
Sign up for my email list and receive my free guide to the:
"Top three reoccurring challenges in ultrasonic transducer development"
Let’s talk about your project!
Have a question or comment? Email me.
Join over 3000 subscribers to have early access to new articles, guides, video tutorials, and more.
husain@
ultrasonicadvisors.com
Ultrasonic Advisors LLC © 2023
Detroit, MI, USA
I hosted a webinar on January 26, 2024 on " Everything you need to know about designing and assembling power ultrasonic transducers " You can watch the recording on my YouTube Channel here: https://youtu.be/oAMjCGBXYms Here is a link to the pdf of the presentation notes: Webinar 24 - everything power transducers.pdf Summary In this webinar I gave a "catch-all" presentation on bolt-clamped ultrasonic power transducer. Specifically, I discussed: -How to design a power ultrasonic transducer (bolt-clamped) -How to assembly the transducer - How to test the transducer *** Announcement *** My next webinar will be on Friday, February 23, 2023 at 11AM EST. I will cover "How to determine to determine the requirements of your transducer application using an R&D electrical driver” (Topic will change based on LinkedIn poll to come) Here is the link to sign up for the upcoming webinar: https://www.ultrasonicadvisors.com/monthly-ultrasonic-webinar
I hosted a webinar on December 29, 2023 on " What happens to displacement at the antiresonance frequency of an ultrasonic transducer " You can watch the recording on my YouTube Channel here: https://youtu.be/Zj9fXkaEADw Here is a link to the pdf of the whiteboard notes: Webinar 23 antiresonance displacement.pdf Here is a link to the Waveforms workspace file: webinar23_wvforms_displacement.dwf3work Summary Using a laser doppler vibrometer, I demonstrate that the mechanical displacement is not affected by the antiresonance phenomenon of ultrasonic transducers. In this webinar, I show experiments and talk about theory. I also talk about mechanical antiresonance. *** Announcement *** My next webinar will be on Friday, January 5, 2023 at 11AM EST. I will cover "How to measure the accuracy and linearity of an laser doppler vibrometer for ultrasonic transducers” Here is the link to sign up for the upcoming webinar: https://www.ultrasonicadvisors.com/monthly-ultrasonic-webinar
How to use multiple transformers to increase voltage and power delivered to an ultrasonic transducer
I hosted a webinar on December 15, 2023 on " How to use multiple transformers to increase voltage and power delivered to an ultrasonic transducer " You can watch the recording on my YouTube Channel here: https://youtu.be/Xb8JaKivXzw Here is a link to the pdf of the whiteboard notes: Webinar22_double_transformers pdf Summary In this webinar, I (1) Describe the use cases of using 2 or more transformers (2) Demonstrate voltage doubling using two off the shelf transformers *** Announcement *** My next webinar will be on Friday, December 29, 2023 at 11AM EST. I will cover "What is the difference in vibrometer measurements of an ultrasonic transducer at anti-resonance and at resonance” Here is the link to sign up for the upcoming webinar: https://www.ultrasonicadvisors.com/monthly-ultrasonic-webinar
I hosted a webinar on December 8, 2023 on " How to make Impedance Measurements of Ultrasonic Transducers with the Digilent Analog Discovery " You can watch the recording on my YouTube Channel here: https://youtu.be/B8llEdp1X2o Here is a link to the pdf of the whiteboard notes: webinar21_digilent_impedance.pdf Here is a link to the calculation script: analog_discovery_impedance_script.txt Summary In this webinar, I show how to make impedance measurements of ultrasonic transducer with the Digilent Analog Discovery. I go over the following topics: (1) Overview of hardware (2) Settings overview and measuring the accuracy of the measurements (3) Measure impedance response of ultrasonic transducer – like an expert! *** Announcement *** My next webinar will be on Friday, December 15, 2023 at 11AM EST. I will cover "How to use two transformers to double voltage gain in an ultrasonic transducer drive circuit” Here is the link to sign up for the upcoming webinar: https://www.ultrasonicadvisors.com/monthly-ultrasonic-webinar
I hosted a webinar on November 24, 2023 on " How to measure the d33 coefficient of a piezo ceramic by applying a force and measuring a voltage " You can watch the recording on my YouTube Channel here: https://youtu.be/xvy5jdbIEQQ Here is a link to the pdf of the whiteboard notes: Webinar 20 notes - custom 10x probe Summary In this webinar, I describe the theory of a 10x probe and practically how to make your own very simple 10x probe that does not require any compensation. This is super useful for ultrasonic and audio work. *** Announcement *** My next webinar will be on Friday, December 1, 2023 at 11AM EST. I will cover "How to make impedance measurements of ultrasonic transducers using the Diligent Analog Discovery” Here is the link to sign up for the upcoming webinar: https://www.ultrasonicadvisors.com/monthly-ultrasonic-webinar